How to Avoid Scams When Publishing Your LLC in New York

The Short Answer

Yes, LLC publication scams exist in New York. Fraudulent companies monitor state business filings and send deceptive mailings to new LLC owners, charging inflated fees ($60-$1,000+ extra) for simple tasks you can handle yourself or get done legitimately. This guide will help you identify red flags, verify legitimate services, and avoid overpaying for your Section 206 publication requirement.

When you file your New York LLC, you become a target. Within days or weeks, you'll likely receive official-looking mail from companies offering to "handle your publication requirement" for fees ranging from hundreds to over a thousand dollars more than necessary. Understanding how to spot these scams protects both your money and your LLC's compliance status.

How Publication Scams Target New LLC Owners

The Scam Process

Third-party companies monitor New York Department of State business filings in real time. When your LLC Articles of Organization become public record, these companies extract your information and immediately send mailings designed to look like official government correspondence.

Here's how the scam works:

1. Immediate targeting - You receive mail within 1-3 weeks of filing your LLC
2. Official appearance - Letters use government-style formatting, official seals, or urgent language
3. Inflated pricing - They charge $600-$1,000+ for "handling" newspaper contacts worth $40-200 in actual work
4. Pressure tactics - Claims of "deadline approaching" or "mandatory filing" create urgency
5. Hidden disclaimers - Fine print admits they're "not affiliated with any government agency"

These companies aren't necessarily illegal—many provide the service they promise—but they exploit inexperienced business owners who don't understand the publication requirement or know what legitimate costs should be.

Why These Scams Work

The New York LLC publication requirement is unique and confusing. Only New York and Nebraska require newspaper publication for LLCs, making it unfamiliar to most entrepreneurs. This creates perfect conditions for exploitation:

• Complexity - The Section 206 requirement involves newspapers, county clerks, affidavits, and state filing
• Urgency - The 120-day deadline creates pressure
• Unfamiliarity - First-time LLC owners don't know typical costs
• Official appearance - Scam letters mimic government communications
• Information asymmetry - New owners don't know where to verify legitimacy

Red Flags: How to Spot Publication Scams

Warning Sign #1: Unsolicited Mail Shortly After Filing

Red flag: You receive mail offering publication services within days or weeks of filing your LLC, without requesting information from that company.

Why it matters: Legitimate publication service providers don't monitor state filings to send unsolicited offers. If you didn't request information, the sender obtained your LLC details from public records specifically to solicit you.

What to look for:

• Mail arrives 1-4 weeks after filing
• You never contacted the company
• The letter implies it's a required response to your filing

Warning Sign #2: Official-Looking But Not Official

Red flag: The correspondence uses government-style formatting, seals, or language but includes a disclaimer (often in fine print) stating "not affiliated with any government agency."

Why it matters: By law, these companies must disclose they're private businesses, not government agencies. They bury this disclaimer in fine print while making everything else look official.

What to look for:

• Official-looking seals or headers
• Language like "Notice," "Required Filing," or "Compliance Deadline"
• Small-print disclaimer: "This company is not affiliated with any government or state agency"
• Return address that's not the NY Department of State

Warning Sign #3: Exorbitant Fees for Simple Tasks

Red flag: The company charges $800-$1,500+ for "full-service publication," which is just contacting two newspapers on your behalf.

Why it matters: Newspaper publication costs vary by county ($200-$1,800 for the actual newspaper ads), but the administrative work of contacting newspapers and filing paperwork shouldn't cost hundreds extra.

Typical legitimate costs:

• Newspaper ads: $200-$1,800 (county-dependent)
• Certificate of Publication filing fee: $50 (paid to NY Department of State)
• Legitimate service fee: $200-400 for full-service coordination

If you're seeing total costs of $2,000-$3,000 from an unsolicited mailer, you're likely looking at inflated pricing.

Warning Sign #4: Pressure Tactics and False Urgency

Red flag: The letter uses urgent language like "IMMEDIATE ACTION REQUIRED," "FINAL NOTICE," or "Your LLC is at risk of suspension."

Why it matters: While the 120-day publication deadline is real, legitimate service providers don't use fear tactics. You have time to research options.

What to look for:

• ALL CAPS warnings
• Highlighted or bolded "URGENT" messages
• Threats of suspension (true, but used manipulatively)
• Artificial deadlines shorter than your actual 120-day window

Warning Sign #5: No Transparent Pricing Breakdown

Red flag: The offer doesn't clearly separate newspaper costs, state filing fees, and service charges.

Why it matters: Legitimate providers itemize costs so you understand what you're paying for. Scammers bundle everything into one inflated price.

What a legitimate breakdown looks like:

• Newspaper publication costs: $[varies by county]
• NY DOS filing fee: $50
• Service coordination fee: $[clearly stated]
• Total: $[sum of above]

Avoid any service that only shows a total price without itemization.

How to Verify Legitimate Publication Services

Step 1: Verify Newspapers Are County-Approved

Under New York LLC Law Section 206, you must publish in two newspapers designated by your county clerk—one daily and one weekly.

How to verify:

1. Contact your county clerk directly

   • Call or email your county clerk's office
   • Request the current list of designated newspapers for LLC publication
   • Ask specifically: "Which newspapers are currently approved for LLC publication in [your county]?"

2. Check the county clerk's website

   • Many counties publish approved newspaper lists online
   • Examples: Queens County, Ulster County, Orange County

3. Verify approval status at publication time

   • Newspapers must be approved when your ad runs, not just historically
   • If newspapers close or lose approval, your publication won't count

Red flag if:

• The service won't tell you which newspapers they'll use
• They claim "we handle newspaper selection" without naming them
• The newspapers they name aren't on your county clerk's current list

Step 2: Confirm the $50 State Filing Fee

The New York Department of State Certificate of Publication filing fee is exactly $50. This is a government fee, not negotiable, and the same regardless of which service you use.

Red flag if:

• The service charges more than $50 for "state filing"
• They describe this as a "processing fee" and charge extra
• The fee breakdown doesn't explicitly show "$50 NY DOS filing fee"

Step 3: Research the Company

Before paying any publication service:

Google the company name + "scam" or "complaints"

• Look for reviews, complaints, or warnings
• Check Better Business Bureau ratings
• Search for mentions on Reddit, legal forums, or small business communities

Verify business registration

• Check if the company is registered with the NY Department of State
• Look for a physical address (not just a P.O. box)
• Verify contact information (phone number, email, website)

Ask for references or testimonials

• Legitimate companies can provide customer references
• Check independent review platforms (not just testimonials on their site)

Step 4: Compare Pricing to County Averages

Publication costs vary dramatically by county due to newspaper advertising rates:

Note: These are newspaper ad costs only, not including service fees or the $50 state filing fee.

If a service quotes you:

• Less than the county average: verify they're using approved newspapers
• Significantly more than the county average + reasonable service fee: likely overcharging

What to Do If You've Already Paid a Scam Service

If They Haven't Performed the Service Yet

1. Request immediate cancellation in writing

   • Email and mail a cancellation letter
   • Request full refund
   • Keep copies of all correspondence

2. Check your payment method

   • If paid by credit card, dispute the charge with your card issuer
   • Document why it's fraudulent or misrepresented
   • Act quickly—dispute windows are time-limited

3. File complaints

   • NY Attorney General's Office
   • Better Business Bureau
   • Federal Trade Commission

If They've Already Published

Even if you overpaid, check if the publication was done correctly:

Verify the publication meets Section 206 requirements:

• Published for six consecutive weeks
• In two county-approved newspapers (one daily, one weekly)
• Contains required information (LLC name, county, purpose, etc.)
• Newspapers provide proper affidavits of publication

If the publication was valid:

• You overpaid, but your compliance requirement may be satisfied
• File complaints about deceptive practices, but focus on completing your Certificate of Publication filing
• Learn from the experience for future business needs

If the publication was invalid:

• You'll need to republish correctly
• Document the invalid publication as evidence in complaints
• Consider legal action to recover costs if significant

How LLC Publishers Provides Transparent Service

We understand the publication requirement is confusing and that new LLC owners are vulnerable to scams. That's why we built our service with complete transparency:

Our Pricing Model

All-inclusive pricing from $395 (Westchester)—your county determines the price. See exact pricing →

This includes:

• Newspaper designation verification with your county clerk
• Coordination with both newspapers (daily and weekly)
• Six weeks of publication in county-approved newspapers
• Collection of affidavits from both newspapers
• Preparation of Certificate of Publication
• Filing with NY Department of State (includes $50 state fee)
• Confirmation of completion

What you pay separately: Nothing. Our all-inclusive price covers everything.

Why We're Different

1. We explain the process - We want you to understand what you're paying for
2. County-specific pricing - Our fee reflects actual newspaper costs in expensive counties
3. No pressure tactics - We don't send unsolicited mail or use scare tactics
4. Full transparency - We name the newspapers, show the timeline, and itemize what's included
5. No hidden fees - One all-inclusive price from start to state filing. View pricing →

When DIY Makes Sense

We openly acknowledge: You don't need us if:

• You're comfortable contacting county clerks and newspapers directly
• You have time to manage the six-week publication and follow-up
• You're in a low-cost county (Albany, for example)
• You're experienced with this process

You benefit from our service if:

• You want someone to handle the entire process
• You're unsure which newspapers to use
• You don't have time to coordinate over six weeks
• You're in an expensive county and want competitive pricing
• You value peace of mind and guaranteed completion

We're transparent because our goal is long-term trust, not one-time manipulation.

Step-by-Step: Safely Completing Publication Yourself

If you prefer to handle publication yourself and avoid all third-party services, here's the legitimate process:

Step 1: Get Newspaper Designation from County Clerk

Within a few days of filing your LLC:

1. Contact your county clerk's office (call or email)
2. Provide your LLC name and filing date
3. Request newspaper designation for LLC publication under Section 206
4. County clerk will designate two newspapers: one daily, one weekly
5. Get this designation in writing or email

County clerk contact info: Search "[Your County] New York county clerk LLC publication" to find contact details.

Step 2: Contact Both Newspapers Directly

Once you have the designation:

1. Call or email both newspapers (the daily and the weekly)
2. Tell them: "I need to publish my LLC formation notice under Section 206"
3. Provide your LLC information:
   • LLC name exactly as filed
   • County where LLC office is located
   • Date of filing
   • Any other info the newspaper requires
4. Ask for pricing and timeline
5. Get a quote in writing before proceeding

What to include in the notice: Most newspapers have templates for Section 206 notices. The notice must include your LLC name, the county of your LLC office, the date of filing, and a statement of formation.

Step 3: Publish for Six Consecutive Weeks

• The newspapers will run your notice once per week for six consecutive weeks
• You typically pay the newspapers directly (either upfront or after publication)
• Costs vary: $100-$900 per newspaper depending on county and circulation

Step 4: Obtain Affidavits of Publication

After the sixth week:

1. Each newspaper will provide an "Affidavit of Publication"
2. This is a notarized statement confirming your notice ran for six consecutive weeks
3. Request original affidavits (not copies) for state filing
4. Newspapers typically mail these within 1-2 weeks after the final publication

Step 5: File Certificate of Publication with NY DOS

Within 120 days of LLC formation:

1. Complete the Certificate of Publication form (available on NY DOS website)

2. Attach both original affidavits from the newspapers

3. Include $50 filing fee (check or money order payable to "Department of State")

4. Mail to:

   NY Department of State Division of Corporations One Commerce Plaza 99 Washington Avenue Albany, NY 12231

5. Keep copies of everything for your records

Processing time: Typically 1-2 weeks for standard processing. Expedited options available for additional fees ($25-$150).

Total DIY Cost

Low-cost county (Albany): $200-500 total Mid-cost county (Queens): $600-1,000 total High-cost county (Manhattan): $1,200-2,000 total

These are actual newspaper ad costs + $50 state fee. Your time investment is approximately 3-5 hours spread over six weeks.

Common Questions About Publication Scams

How do scam companies get my information so quickly?

New York LLC filings are public record. Companies monitor the Department of State's business entity database and extract information from newly filed LLCs. This is legal—it's the deceptive marketing that's problematic.

Are all unsolicited publication offers scams?

Not necessarily "scams" in the illegal sense, but many are overpriced services using deceptive marketing. Some companies provide the service they promise—they just charge 2-3 times what it should cost and use manipulative tactics to get you to buy.

What if I already responded to a suspicious offer?

If you haven't paid yet, don't. If you paid by credit card, contact your card issuer immediately to dispute the charge. If you paid by check and it hasn't cleared, contact your bank to stop payment. Document everything and file complaints with the NY Attorney General and FTC.

Can I get in trouble for using the wrong service?

Not directly. Your concern is whether the publication was done correctly according to Section 206. If the service used non-approved newspapers or didn't publish for six consecutive weeks, the NY Department of State will reject your Certificate of Publication, and you'll need to republish correctly. This could cause you to miss the 120-day deadline, resulting in LLC suspension.

How can I tell if a company is legitimate?

Legitimate characteristics:

• Clear pricing with itemized breakdown
• Willingness to name the newspapers they'll use
• No pressure tactics or artificial urgency
• Registered business with verifiable address and contact info
• Positive independent reviews
• Transparent about the process and timeline

What happens if I miss the 120-day deadline while dealing with a scam?

If you miss the deadline, your LLC's authority to conduct business will be suspended under Section 206. You can still complete publication after the deadline, but your LLC can't legally operate until you file the Certificate of Publication and the suspension is lifted. This can affect contracts, bank accounts, and legal protections.

Are online-only newspapers acceptable for Section 206?

No. The publication requirement specifically requires newspapers that print physical editions. Online-only publications don't satisfy Section 206. Learn more in our guide: Can I Use an Online Newspaper for My NY LLC Publication?

Do I need to use a service, or can I do this myself?

You can absolutely do this yourself. The process is straightforward if you follow the steps outlined above. Services exist for convenience, time savings, and guaranteed compliance—but they're not legally required.

Key Takeaways

• Scams target new LLC owners within weeks of filing by monitoring public business records and sending deceptive mailings
• Red flags include unsolicited mail, official-looking formatting with disclaimers, exorbitant fees, pressure tactics, and lack of transparent pricing
• Verify legitimacy by checking county clerk newspaper approval, confirming the $50 state fee, researching the company, and comparing pricing to county averages
• The DIY process is legal and straightforward: get county clerk designation → contact newspapers → publish for six weeks → obtain affidavits → file Certificate of Publication with $50 fee
• Total legitimate costs range from $200-$2,000 depending on county, plus a reasonable service fee ($200-400) if using a provider
• If you've been scammed, act quickly: cancel if possible, dispute charges, file complaints, and verify if publication was done correctly
• Legitimate providers offer transparent pricing, itemized breakdowns, no pressure tactics, and clear explanations of the process

Disclaimer

The information in this article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive for accuracy, laws and procedures may change. For specific legal questions about your LLC or concerns about fraudulent solicitations, consult with a qualified attorney. LLC Publishers provides publication services and administrative filing assistance, but we are not a law firm and cannot provide legal advice. Always verify any service provider before payment, and report suspected fraud to appropriate authorities.

---

Need trustworthy publication service? Get started with our transparent all-inclusive service or view pricing.